Throughout the eighties and into the nineties, work stress have continued to rise
dramatically in organizations across North America. The eighties saw employees
stressing out from working in a rapidly growing economy. During the nineties, beginning
from the recession of 1992 till present day, employees are stressed by their own job
insecurities in the face of massive downsizing and restructuring of organizations in
order to be competitive on the global stage. Work stress is a very extensive topic
ranging from research on the sources of stress, the effects of stress, to ways on
managing and reducing stress. This report will focus first on the evidence for the
harmful effects of stress at work, both mentally and physically. The last section will
briefly explain why management should be concerned with rising employee stress and will
describe some actions management can take to alleviate work stress.
2.0 Harmful Effects of Stress
Most research studies indicate a high correlation between stress and illness. According
to authorities in the United States and Great Britain, as much as 70% of patients that
are treated by general practitioners are suffering from symptoms originating from stress
. Everyone experiences stress, however, each person responds to stress very differently.
Their response is dependent on how each person reacts to stress emotionally, mentally,
and physically. There are, however, common effects of stress for most people on the
physical and mental body.
2.1 Physical Effects
The researcher Blyth in 1973 identified a list of diseases which have a fairly high
causal relationships with stress. His evidence was obtained through interviews with
medical experts, review of reports by the World Health Organization and consultations
with the J.R. Geigy Pharmaceutical Company. The following is a list of some of the
illnesses Blyth had identified :
1. Hypertension2. Coronary thrombosis3. Hay fever and other allergies4. Migraine
headaches5. Intense itching6. Asthma7. Peptic ulcers8. Constipation 9. Rheumatoid
arthritis10. Colitis11. Menstrual difficulties12. Nervous dyspepsia 13. Overactive
thyroid gland14. Skin disorders15. Diabetes mellitus16. Tuberculosis
Research conducted by Woolfolk and Richardson in 1978 further confirmed Blyth's list that
hypertension, coronary disease, infections, and ulcers are highly related to the amount
of prolonged stress an employee is subjected to. Evidence for a causal relationship
between hypertension and stress was seen in a study of air traffic controllers. The work
stress is enormous for this occupation due to the high responsibility for the safety of
others that people is this field must bear. This study noted that air traffic
controllers experiences a hypertension rate approximately 5 times greater than other
comparable occupational groups .
Only in recent studies was stress linked to coronary disease. As the majority of heart
attacks are caused by fatty substances adhering to the artery walls (arteriosclerosis),
stress is a causal factor in that, at high levels, the amounts of the two fatty
substances, cholesterol and triglycerides, in the blood steam are elevated. This is
evidenced in one study of tax accountants. As the deadline for the annual tax filing
drew nearer, cholesterol levels rose without decreasing until 2 months later. The
situation here shows that cholesterol in the blood rises gradually with constant exposure
to stress.
There is also strong evidence for the causal relationship between stress and infectious
disease. Woolfolk was able to show that employees that are very fatigue (a symptom of
stress) were more susceptible to infections. In his study conducted upon 24 woman
during the flu season, every woman was administered a certain amount of flu virus into
their blood stream. Woman in the group who were fatigued were administered a smaller
dose than those who were not. Woolfolk found that the women who had just gone through
very stressful experiences were more susceptible to the infection despite a very small
dosage of the flu virus. The other women who were not tired did not get infected even
though they had considerably high dosages of flu virus in them .
Lastly, evidence that ulcers are associated with high stress levels have been
conclusively proven by Woolfolk. Ulcers occur when digestive juices burn a hole in the
stomach lining. A person under stress or anxiety would stimulate the rapid secretion of
digestive juices into the stomach. Thus, when a person is subjected to constant tension
and frustration, he / she has a high likelihood that an ulcer would occur. Evidence for
this was provided by the study performed by Dr. Steward Wolf. He was able to monitor
activities of a patient stomach, and where the patient responded to an emotional
situation, he observed the excessive secretion of stomach acids. Woolfolk and
Richardson further the studies by showing increased levels of stomach acids during high
exposure to stress.
2.1 Psychological Effects
Most organizations have recognize that stress can have an adverse effect on the
efficiency of their employees. In 1978, the International Association of Chiefs of
Police (IACP) cited their study report that there are essentially three psychological
reactions to consistently high stress levels: repression of emotion, displacement of
anger, and isolation.
Repression of emotions occur often in human service professionals such as policemen or
accountants. Their roles demand that they suppress their emotions when interacting with
clients. Thus, when the stress levels begin to rise as they deal with more and more
clients, they would put up an even greater resistance to their own emotions . Over time,
the professional may not be able to relax that emotional resistance. All their emotions
would be masked and retained within themselves, resulting ultimately in mental and
emotional disorders.
In stressful times, employees are often displeased or angry with something. However,
there are usually limited channels in which employees can express their views. Since
opinions, views, and feelings cannot always be expressed to anyone to change the current
situation, there would be an accumulation of anger and frustration within the individual.
Up to a certain point, the anger would be released, usually at the wrong person or time,
such as colleagues, clients, or family members. This symptom has a tremendous impact on
society because there is a potential that it may hurt others people. Take for example
the US postal shootings over last few years. All of them were a result of accumulated
anger and frustration of US postal workers where they eventually released all that
pent-up anger at one time towards other colleagues. Moreover, many cases of spousal
abuse, child abuse, alcohol abuse, dysfunctional families are a result of overstressed
employees unable to diffuse or cope with the anger and frustration building up within
them.
The 1978 IACP's report stated that isolation is a common side-effect of working under
tremendous stress. For many service practitioners, they are not always readily welcomed
by the clients that they serve. A prime example would be policemen who are shunned often
by the public. Over time, a feeling of isolation and rejection would envelop the person.
The natural thing to do would be to withdraw from others who do not understand their
plight, resulting in profound human loneliness .
The symptoms mentioned above are usually long-term effects. There are many other short
term, psychological effects of stress that can be readily seen or felt. The following is
by no means a
definitive list of mental effects as it only illustrates some of the symptoms that
could readily identified in a person under constant stress :
1. Constant feeling of uneasiness2. Irritability towards others3. General sense of
boredom4. Recurring feelings of hopelessness in life5. Anxiety regarding money6.
Irrational fear of disease7. Fear of death8. Feelings of suppressed anger9. Withdrawn and
isolated 10. Feelings of rejection by others (low self-esteem)11. Feelings of despair at
failing as a parent12. Feelings of dread toward an approaching weekend13. Reluctance to
vacation14. Sense that problems cannot be discussed with others15. Short attention
span16. Claustrophobic
3.0 Management's Role in Reducing Work Stress
Employee stress can have an enormous impact to an organization in terms of cost. As many
studies have shown, there is a high correlation between stress and job performance. At
moderate levels, stress is beneficial in that it can cause individuals to perform their
jobs better and attain higher job performance. However, at high levels, stress can
decrease productivity instead. This is the case often seen in employees at many
organizations . Furthermore, aside from costs associated with lost productivity, there
are costs with respect to stress-related absenteeism and organizational medical expenses.
Specifically, these include costs of lost company time, increases in work-related
accidents disrupting production, increases in health care costs and health insurance
premiums, and most importantly, decreases in productivity .
There are numerous methods that organizations could adopt to reduce undue stress in their
employees. However, measures taken to counter this problem are usually tailored
specifically for the particular organization. Therefore, this report has chosen two
separate actions which are fundamental to most organizations that management can take.
3.1 Reduction of Employee Stress as an Organizational Policy
The first step any organization should take to help its employees reduce and cope with
stress is to incorporate into the company policies a positive and specific intent on
reducing undue stress. This would indicate that top management is committed to such a
stress reduction program. Furthermore, the amendment to the policies should also include
a recognition that this initiative will benefit the achievement of other organizational
goals by enhancing the productivity of employees through lowered stress levels . After
the inclusion of the broad mission goal of reducing employee stress, management should
draft out plans which specifically lays out the provisions to accomplish that goal. As
earlier mentioned, there are many approaches to stress reduction, thus the provisions
should detail only the methods specific to the organization. For example, they could
specify that employees undergo periodic physical and psychological examinations and
personnel surveys to ascertain current stress levels. Another alternative would be to
provide personal counseling to employees to identify undue stress levels and then to
advise any corrective measures for the individual. In any case, the most important
beginning step is a total reexamination and revision of company policies, plans, and
procedures to enhance employees' own methods of coping with stress, and simultaneously,
promote an organizational climate which actively assists employees to minimize their
stress.
3.2 Fundamental Techniques to Employee Stress Reduction
One method management can employ to alleviate employee stress is to make them fitter to
deal with the everyday pressures of work . There are three basic management techniques
that would accomplish this goal. Managers should be clear about their expectations of
employees and clearly convey these expectations to each person. Secondly, management
should devise a performance-evaluation-feedback system such that each employee would be
aware of his / her performance level based on the feedback received. Lastly, employees
should be fully capable of performing their job tasks. Stress arises when employees do
not possess the necessary skills to carry on with the work assigned to them. Therefore,
job training programs are essential to reducing anxiety and stress associated when
employees feel that they do not possess sufficient skills or knowledge to perform the job
that they were hired for.
3.2.1 Communicating Management's Expectations
In an organization, it would appear that all employees have a clear understanding of
their roles they were hired for and the duties expected of them. This assertion is
often valid for employees working at the front line, such as workers on an assembly line.
Strict procedural guidelines dictates the tasks and procedures each worker would assume.
However, at higher levels in the organizational hierarchy, an employee's duties and
responsibilities may not be as apparent. A middle manager or team leader's role could
entail many different responsibilities and duties such as managing, coordinating,
leading, planning, etc. Despite a detailed job description when the individual was
hired, there often exists a cloud of ambiguity as to what the position exactly
encompasses given the wide-ranging scope of the position . Work stress arises as a
result of this because employees would be distressed over uncertainty of the sufficiency
of their tasks in relevance to their position and role. Furthermore, employees may not
be clear as to the amount of work expected of him or her. When employees do not know
how much effort they should commit to their jobs in order to satisfy their superior's
expectations, a certain level of employee work stress would arise in that the individual
would be constantly worried about the adequacy of his / her level of effort. In essence,
employees need to know exactly the tasks expected of them and the level of effort to put
into those tasks.
The issue here is essentially a communications problem between management and employees.
Management should communicate its expectations to employees whether as a group or
individually. Since increased communications is the primary solution in this case,
management should also promote a working environment where employees are encouraged to
voice their concerns, questions, etc. to their respective superiors. Managers,
themselves, should adapt a managing style that is sensitive and responsive to employee
stress. Communication of management expectations can be achieved by analyzing each role
in the organization to clarify priorities and resolve conflict between roles. This
approach would first, clarify any ambiguity an employee may have about his / her
position. Secondly, it effectively eliminates the stress from not knowing what or how
much to do. Informing employees of their role expectations is only the beginning to
reducing stress levels . Employee also require feedback from their performance
measures.
3.2.2 Providing Feedback to Employees
Once role expectations are known, employees require feedback on their performance to
determine whether those expectations are met. In the absence of feedback, employees
would be worrying if their current levels of effort are satisfying the expectations of
them. A state of ambiguity would arise again, resulting in increased stress levels.
A systematic approach in providing periodical performance feedback to all employees in
the organization is required. One common approach adopted by many companies are staff
and staff-development schemes. They entail a periodical one-on-one interview between
managers and each of his / her subordinates. During the interview, the manager would
inform the employee of his / her performance relative to previously set standards (ie.
expectations). The employee would be encouraged to provide his / her concerns regarding
the performance evaluation. Any problems and / or requests for assistance would be
communicated to the manager at this point. To conclude the interview, the employee
would set attainable future goals to improve or maintain the current performance level.
Royal Bank is a strong advocate of staff-development schemes. Employees meet with their
managers once every four months to discuss the employees' performance to-date. The
interview process is characterized by the supportive and encouraging roles every manager
adopts towards their subordinates. Unlike many other appraisal interviews, managers do
not only focus and highlight employee weaknesses. When certain deficiencies in
performance are discussed, managers recognize that negative feedback is uncomfortable to
both parties and can also be counter-productive. Thus, they usually identify areas for
improvement to employees in a very supportive approach. The objective is to rectify the
deficiency by motivating the employee to change, rather than imposing additional stress
on him / her by merely pointing the weakness(s) out.
3.1.3 Job Training Programs
Job training programs provide employees with a broader knowledge and skills enabling them
to better handle the expectations from their roles. Employee stress is often caused by
the lack of skills or knowledge to meet designated objectives and goals. These programs
usually take on two forms - knowledge-based development and skills-based development.
Knowledge-based development programs usually involve a conference or seminar where the
aim is to broaden the attendees' knowledge of a certain topic such as infomatics seminar
briefing employees on the latest networking technologies. The knowledge gained from such
programs may or may not be utilized in the everyday job routines of employees.
Alternatively, skill-based development programs focus on training employees to become
more proficient in the use of certain behaviours such as assertiveness training. While
job training programs can reduce work stress, there are essentially three conditions to
its success . First, the job training must be required by the employee. No benefit
would be derived if an employee is trained for something that is not relevant to the work
he / she performs everyday. Secondly, management must discourage any perception by
employees that training programs are a form of reward or punishment, or else the entire
purpose of the training initiative would be lost. Finally, preparation is required to
benefit fully from the program.
4.0 Conclusion
Work stress places a very high toll on both employees and employers. An employee
subjected to high levels of stress could experience both physical and mental
side-effects. Physical side effects such as hypertension, coronary disease, infections,
ulcers could greatly decrease the lifespan of the person. The psychological effects such
as repressed emotions, anger, and isolation have a direct negative impact on
organizational productivity. Thus, organizations have a great responsibility in
reducing the stress of their employees, and in general be concerned about their
well-being.
There are numerous methods to counter the stress problem. The report has cited only the
basics which are applicable to most organizations. The first step for management is to
set out the intention to reduce employee stress in as an organizational goal. Provisions
detailing the organization's planned approach should be drafted.
Informing employees of management's expectations is one method to reduce a large portion
of the anxiety employees may have about their jobs. Secondly, management must provide
subordinates feedback on their performance. Management should also provide job training
for all employees to enable them to better perform their jobs and reduce the stress
associated with the feeling of inadequacy to perform one's duties.
Bibliography
Alluisi, E. A., Fleishman, E. A. (1981). Stress and performance effectiveness.
Hillsdale, N.J.: L. Erlbaum Associates.
Arroba, T., James, K. (1987). Pressure at work: a survival guide. London; Montreal:
McGraw-Hill.
Greenberg, S. F., Valletutti, P. J. (1980). Stress and the helping professions.
Baltimore: P. H. Brookes.
Greenwood, J. W. (1979). Managing executive stress: a systems approach. New York;
Chichester: Wiley.
Kompier, M. (1994). Stress at work: Does it concern you?. Shankill, Ireland: European
Foundation for the Improvement of Living & Working Conditions.
Robbins, S. (1996). Organizational behaviour: concepts. controversies, applications.
Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall Inc.
Smither, R. D. (1988). The psychology of work and human performance. New York: Harper &
Row.
|