The Effect of Salt De-icing on the Environment
As awareness for pollution increases, other forms of pollution are defined. Almost
everyone knows about toxic waste and carbon dioxide pollution, but not many people have
heard of salt pollution. Salt pollution has been on the increase since the evolution of
the automobile. With more pressure on government agencies to keep the highway clear and
safe, an increase in the use of salt has developed. It is important to understand why
salt is used and how it work as well as the environmental effects to understand the salt
pollution problem.
Salt is a necessary and accepted part of the winter environment. It provides safety and
mobility for motorists, commercial vehicles and emergency vehicles.
Salt is used as the principal deicer because it is the most available and cost-effective
deicer. Rock salt is preferred because it is cheap and effective. It costs 20 dollars a
ton where as an alternative like calcium magnesium cost around 700 dollars a ton. Some 10
million tons of deicing salt is used each year in the U.S. and about 3 million in
Canada.
Salt is used to keep snow and ice from bonding to the pavement and to allow snowplows to
remove. When salt is applied to ice and snow it creates a brine that has a lower
freezing temperature than the surrounding ice or snow. Salt is the ideal deicing material
because it is:
?the least expensive deicer
?easy to spread
?easy to store and handle
?readily available
?non-toxic
?harmless to skin and clothing
Salt pollution is broken into two main groups. Water, which includes the effects on
ground water, surface water and aquatic life and land.
Most of the salt applied to the roadways eventually ends up in the ground water. It is
estimated that 30% to 50% of the salt used travels into the ground water. Salt effect
two areas of ground water, chloride concentration and sodium concentration. Chlorides
may be present in the form of sodium chloride crystals or as a ion in a solution. Normal
concentrations in the water are average around 10 mg/litre. Concentrations found in
ground water near major highways have been recorded as high as 250 mg/litre which is
around the threshold of taste.
The main factor with ground water pollution is the risk to human health. The raised
level in sodium in water can cause high blood pressure and hypertension. With people who
already suffer from these problem it is necessary to keep their salt intake relatively
low, they should not drink water above 20 mg/liter. Although this is recommended, a
study of private well water in Toronto showed that half the wells exceeded this limit,
twenty percent exceeded 100 mg/litre and six percent exceeded 250 mg/litre. This
increase in sodium and chlorine can also cause problem with water balance in the human
body.
As well as surface water, ground water is also affected by road salting. Although the
effects are not as great as ground water, they still pose problems to the environment.
The problems are based on the salt ions. The salt ions interact with heavy metal that
fall to the bottom of the body of water. An example of this is when sodium and chlorine
ions compete for mercury to bond with. This cause the release of mercury into the water
system. The risk of mercury poisoning is far greater than that of sodium or chlorine.
This increase of sodium and chlorine as well as mercury and other heavy metal also cause
changes in the pH of water.
The increase of salt around bodies of water also effect aquatic life in the area. Two
main areas that are effected are osmotic regulation in fish and the death of micro-biotic
life in ponds and lakes. Most fish life can only tolerate a narrow range of salt content
in the water. The increase of salt in the water produced by road de-icing cause
freshwater fish to swell up with water. The increased salt cause a lower concentration
of water in the fishes cells. To compensate, the fishes body takes in water to restore
equilibrium. This can kill fish if the salt concentration becomes to high.
Just as important as fish, microorganisms are also effected in a detrimental way.
Microrganisms are tiny organism that sustain aquatic life in all bodies of water. They
are more susceptible to the effect of salt pollution than fish. These microorganism are
at the bottom of the food chain, when they die, it doesn't take long for the rest of the
food chain to follow. Large increase in salt concentration can cause 75% - 100% death
for these microorganisms, The effect of salt is almost immediate. Most of the organism
are only one cell big and blow up in contact with increased amounts of salt.
Water insects are also effected by the increase in salt in the environment. The number
of insects lowers because the inability for water insects to reproduces in the presence
of high salt concentrations. With the decreasing numbers in microorganisms, insects and
fish, it is easy to see the effect it would have on the rest of the food chain even
though other animal may be more salt tolerable.
Salt pollution also is a major factor to land. It can also be broken up into the
effects on soil, vegetation and animals.
The effect of salt on soil may seem relatively less important than the other topics
mentioned so far, but it leads up to more important things. The effect salt has on soil
is that it alters the soil structure. Sodium chloride actually deteriorates the structure
of the soil. This cause a decrease in soil fertility. In most cases calcium in the soil
is replaced by sodium in a anion exchange. The make the soil less usable by vegetation.
This also occurs with magnesium. This depletion of calcium and magnesium also causes the
soil to increase in alkalinity with pH of nearly 10. Normal pH for the soils tested were
between 5.4 and 6.6.
High concentrations of sodium in the soil also makes the soil less permeable. In some
case soil may be encrusted in a layer of salt. As a result, moisture content in the soil
may be drastically decreased. High concentrations of salt may also cause clay to have a
decreased concentration of water. This makes the clay harder and vegetation is less
likely to grow.
Although salt already effects the soil vegetation grows in, it also can directly effect
vegetation itself. Vegetation can be dehydrate to the point of death when in contact
with high levels of salt. This occurs because the osmotic stress put on the plant make
it react like it was in a drought. A decrease in roots production and burns to leaf tips
cause the plant to go into shock.
Salt injury will also occur when plants come into contact with increased levels of salt.
Salt injury is when foliage damage is present by leaf burn, die-back, defoliation and
brooming. It can also cause fruit trees to have reduced quantity and quality of fruit.
This occurs with only a small amount of salt comes in contact with the plant. It only
take 0.5% of the plants tissue dry weight to become salt before the plant reach toxic
levels. Increased chlorine levels can also cause salt injury to a plant in the same way.
Salt injury also effect trees as well as small plant life. Growth of plants in also
effected by the presence of sodium and chlorine.
Animal are also greatly effected by roadway de-icing. Although animals tolerance to
salt intake is quite high using salt for de-icing road presents unusual dangers. Moose
and deer become susceptible to salt pollution because of their attraction to salt. Deer
and moose are know to drink the salty water around roads. It becomes an addiction to
them and reduces the level of fear when in contact with cars and people. They have also
been found licking the gravel and the side of the road and even the road itself in search
for salt.
Small animals are effected more by the toxicity of high levels of salt. Increased
levels of salt in small wildlife caused kidney hemorrhaging, depression, excitement,
tremors, incoordination, coma and death. Rabbits seem to be the most susceptible because
their inability to stop consuming salt. Household pets are also effected. once outside,
salt collects on their feet. Pets consume a lot salt when cleaning their feet. This
causes cats and dogs to get inflamed stomachs.
As one can see, the effect of roadway de-icing on the environment are tremendous. The
use of salt causes a great burden to both land and water. One must weigh the pro's and
con's of de-icing when learn about the effects of salt on the environment.
|