The Buddha's Four Noble Truths:
A Logical Basis for Philosophy
The Buddha Shakyamuni was born in the 6th century BCE in the area presently known as
Nepal. During his 80 year lifetime, he systematically developed a pragmatic, empirically
based philosophy which he claimed would lead its followers towards an enlightened
existence. Buddhism is commonly called a religion; however, it differs from the usual
definition of a religion in that it has no deities, does not promote worship of demigods,
and is based on logical reasoning and observation rather than spiritual faith. At the
heart of Buddhist philosophy is the Buddha's enumeration of Four Noble Truths: Dukkha
(suffering), Samudaya (origin of suffering), Nirodha (cessation of suffering), and Magga
(path to cessation of suffering). The Buddha's Four Noble Truths are based on archetypal
traits that were elucidated through careful empirical observance and intensive
introspection. These Four Noble Truths form a logically coherent set of axioms upon
which the whole of Buddhism is based, and provide a solid foundation for a philosophy
which is applicable several millennia after its formulation.{1}
"What we call a 'being,' or an 'individual,' or 'I,' according to Buddhist philosophy, is
only a combination of ever-changing physical and mental forces or energies...."
- Walpola Rahula{2}
In order to fully understand the Four Noble Truths, it is necessary to investigate the
Buddhist view of the individual and its makeup. In some respects, the manner in which
Buddhism deals with the mind/body problem is much more advanced than most religious
views, and closer to science's understanding of the mind and body. Rather than
postulating the existence of an eternal soul with no physical manifestation, the Buddha
taught that the person is really a collection of five skandhas or aggregates. These
include rupa (matter), vedana (sensations), sanna (perceptions), samkhara (mental
formations), and vijnana (consciousness). The aggregate of matter encompasses all
tangible aspects of the world. The aggregate of sensations is akin to the process of
sensory input; e.g., the activation of retinal cells in the eye. Vedana does not include
the process of perception, however; the act of perceiving the senses, i.e., recognition
of external sensations, is within the realm of the sanna. Buddha classified mental
activities (samkhara), i.e., ideas and thoughts, as being disparate from the state of
mental consciousness (vijnana). Consciousness, in the Buddhist view, is the awareness of
the sensations and perceptions that the person experiences, while the mental formations
are the volitions, whims, thoughts, and ideas that a person has. The breakdown of the
individual into the skandhas is strikingly similar to the classifications used in the
modern field of psychology. Matter, sensation, perception, cognition, and consciousness
are common nomenclature in both paradigms.
"There is this Noble Truth of suffering: Birth is suffering, aging is suffering,
sickness is suffering, death is suffering, sorrow and lamentation, pain, grief, and
despair are suffering, association with the loathed is suffering, dissociation from the
loved is suffering, not to get what one wants is suffering...."
- Shakyamuni Buddha{3}
The First Noble Truth, the Truth of Dukkha, is based on Buddha's observation that all
people in the world are in a state of dukkha. Dukkha, which translates literally as
'suffering' from the Pali, does not mean pain or distress as the word 'suffer' usually
implies. Instead it is used to convey the idea that the very act of living is one of
imperfection and impermanence, and hence is a situation that must be remedied in order to
achieve true happiness. There are three types of dukkha: dukkha-dukkha (suffering in
the conventional sense), viparinama-dukkha (suffering caused by the ephemeral nature of
happiness in life), and samkhara-dukkha (suffering caused by existence itself).
Suffering in the conventional sense of the word, such as that caused by pain, disease,
and poverty, is classified as dukkha-dukkha. The Buddha also noted that happiness
itself, being a fleeting emotion, usually resulted in an eventual loss of happiness
greater than the initial happiness. This loss of happiness is caused by the removal of
whatever situation or object precipitated the happiness in the first place; therefore the
transitory nature of life itself is the root of dukkha, in this case called viparinama.
This leads to the conclusion that suffering is an inherent trait of existence itself, and
is classified as samkhara. And thus the question is raised that if suffering is inherent
in life itself, what is the cause (and the remedy) for this undesirable state of affairs?
"There is this noble truth of the origin of suffering: It is craving, which produces
renewal of being, is accompanied by relish and lust, relishing this and that; in other
words, craving for sensual desires, craving for being, craving for nonbeing."
- Shakyamuni Buddha{4}
While dukkha has a variety of direct causes, Buddhist doctrine teaches that at the heart
of all suffering is a basal craving or thirst called tanha. Tanha is defined in the
original texts as "... this thirst which produces re-existence and re-becoming, and which
is bound up with passionate greed, and which finds fresh delight now here and now there
...."{5} There are three sub-divisions of tanha: kama-tanha (desire for sensual
pleasures), bhava-tanha (desire for existence), and vibhava-tanha (desire for
non-existence). These three types of desire have a common effect - they result in the
continuation of suffering and the instantiation of the dukkha. The causal relationship
between the tanha and dukkha is delineated by the related concepts of karma and
karma-phala. Karma is the Sanskrit word for 'action' or 'doing' and it refers to the
actions of a person as a result of his or her mental volition. The result of a person's
karma is called karma-phala, commonly colloquialized as the fruits of karma. The basic
belief in Buddhism about the mechanics of karma is that when a person has a craving
(tanha) of any sort, they will try to attain the thing for which they have the craving
(karma), and in doing so will cause the existence of dukkha in their life. This belief
is another way of viewing the old axiom that "what goes around, comes around," a simple
observation about the nature of cause and effect in relation to human actions.
"There is this noble truth of the cessation of suffering: It is the remainderless
fading and ceasing, the giving up, relinquishing, letting go, and rejecting of that same
craving."
- Shakyamuni Buddha{6}
The goal of a Buddhist is to eliminate all traces of dukkha from his or her life, thus
becoming Enlightened. A person who has attained Enlightenment, according to the Buddha,
is in a state of Nirvana. Nirvana is commonly defined as Tanhakkhaya, or the extinction
of thirst. It is the end of all earthly suffering and freedom from attachment to the
Five Aggregates.{7} While commonly misconstrued as final annihilation, nirvana is simply
the final liberation from the earthly existence, or as the Buddha put it, "... [it is]
the extinction of desire, the extinction of hatred, the extinction of illusion. This, O
bhikkhus, is called the Absolute [Nirvana]."{8} One who is enlightened is able to
realize the absolute truth of any situation without the illusion of earthly existence
interfering.
"There is this noble truth of the way leading to the cessation of suffering: It is this
Noble Eightfold Path, that is to say: right view, right intention, right speech, right
action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration."
- Shakyamuni Buddha{9}
With the goal of Nirvana thus elucidated, the obvious question is "How does one set
about reaching Nirvana?" As with the rest of his philosophy, the Buddha answered this
question through careful empirical observations. In the early days of his life,
Siddhartha lived a life of luxury in which all of the sensual pleasures were given to
him. Finding this an unsatisfactory state of affairs, the Buddha attempted to find
happiness in a life at the opposite extreme. He became a wandering ascetic, practicing
self-denial and abasement for a number of years. After searching for the answer in both
hedonism and puritanism, he realized that the path to Enlightenment must lie somewhere
between these two antipodes. Thus, the Buddha found the Middle Path or the Way leading
to the Cessation of Dukkha, Magga. He declared that eight qualities were required to
follow the path to Nirvana: Right Understanding, Right Thought, Right Speech, Right
Action, Right Livelihood, Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, and Right Concentration. The
rational behind this eightfold path of the Magga is simple - a person who follows it will
be endowed with wisdom (right understanding and right thought), compassion (right speech,
right action, and right livelihood), and mental awareness (right mindfulness and right
concentration). These are the qualities which are both necessary and sufficient to
attain final liberation, Enlightenment, and Nirvana.
Thus is laid out the very heart of the Buddhist doctrine. These four aspects of the
Buddha's philosophy are not lofty, abstract constructs which have no empirical basis.
They are, in the most sincere use of the words, 'The Four Noble Truths.'
FOOTNOTES********************************
{1} The idea of the cycle of death and rebirth, a central tenet to both Buddhist
philosophy and the Hindu religion, will not be brought into this discussion of the Four
Noble Truths. While reincarnation was very important to Buddha's formulation of his
beliefs, it is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for the Four Noble Truths to
hold true. When examined from a purely logical and empirical basis, the Four Noble
Truths are still valid without the introduction of reincarnation.
{2} Walpola Rahula, What the Buddha Taught. Page 25.
{3} Sherab Chodzin Kohn. The Life of the Buddha. Page 19.
{4} Sherab Chodzin Kohn. The Life of the Buddha. Page 19.
{5} Walpola Rahula, What the Buddha Taught. Page 29.
{6} Sherab Chodzin Kohn. The Life of the Buddha. Page 19.
{7} B. Alan Wallace. Tibetan Buddhism From the Ground Up. Pages 40-41.
{8} Walpola Rahula, What the Buddha Taught. Page 36.
{9} Sherab Chodzin Kohn. The Life of the Buddha. Page 19.
|