DISABILITY IN THE WORKPLACE
"The Americans With Disabilities Act is one of the most significant laws in
American History. The preamble to the law states that it covers 43,000,000
Americans."(Frierson, p.3) Before the Americans With Disabilities Act(A.D.A.)
was passed, employers were able to deny employment to a disabled worker, simply because
he or she was disabled. With no other reason other than the persons
physical disability were they turned away or released from a job. The Americans With
Disabilities Act prevented this type of discrimination by establishing rules and
regulations designed to protect persons with physical disabilities. With a workforce
made up of 43,000,000 people, it is impossible to ignore the impact of
these people. The Americans With Disabilities Act not only opened the door for
millions of Americans to get back into the workplace, it is paving the road
for new facilities in the workplace, new training programs and creating
jobs designed for a disabled society.
I believe the Americans With Disabilities Act is the most important precedent
set in the struggle against all discrimination for persons with disability. In
this paper I will give a brief description of the statutes set by the Americans
With Disabilities Act, pertaining to disabilities in the workplace. I will
then discuss what employers are required to do according to the A.D.A. and some
of the regulations they must abide by. The next section of this paper will
discuss the actual training of employees with disabilities with a highlight on
training programs for workers with mobility and motion disabilities. The
following section of this paper will discuss the economic effects of a
vocational rehabilitation program. Finally this paper will conclude with a
brief discussion of what the measures set by the Americans With Disabilities
Act means to the actual workers and people it benefits.
The Americans With Disabilities Act
The Americans With Disabilities Act has a section devoted to nothing but
practices by employers regarding the treatment of applicants and on staff
workers based on their physical condition or any health problems they may have.
Some of the disabilities included are vision, hearing, motion, or mental
impairments. "Title I of the Americans With Disabilities Act prohibits
employers from discriminating against qualified individuals with disabilities
in job application procedures, hiring, firing, advancement, compensation, job
training and other terms and conditions of employment"(The Americans With
Disabilities Act). According to the Americans With Disabilities Act, the only
way an employer can refuse to hire an employee based upon a disability is
if that persons disability imposes an undue hardship on the operation
of the employer's business. Then the question arises, what is considered an
undue hardship? The Americans With Disabilities Act states that an undue
hardship is any action that is considered to be in excessive cost to the
employer, or if the reforms are too extensive, substantial, disruptive to the
goings on of the company or anything that would substantially change the
operation of the business.
In addition to this, the Americans With Disabilities Act provides some information on
what employers cannot do. For instance the A.D.A. states that
"employers may not ask job applicants about the existence, nature, or severity
of a disability"(The Americans With Disabilities Act). This is a very
important step in that it cancels out any possible internal prejudice the
employer may have despite the regulations set by the A.D.A. For example if the employer
has a pre-concieved notion of what he or she believes a disabled person can do, this rule
will protect the applicant from such prejudice. Also, the employer
cannot require an applicant take a medical examination before a job is offered.
Furthermore, that a job can only be conditioned based on the results of a medical
exam if those conditions apply to all workers. This aspect is important
because it places all the employees of that company on the same level right
form the beginning.
These measures have been set not only to put persons with disabilities on level
ground with other applicants, it also protects thier rights as to the kind of
treatment they will recieve. Because of this, more and more people with
disabilities are going out and applying for jobs. With the added
assurance and comfort the A.D.A. provides, disabled workers can go out with
confidence and apply for almost any position.
There is a certain classification set by A.D.A. on what constitutes a person
with a disability, that is if the person has a physical or mental disability
that substantially limits a major life activity. Also, in order to be protected by the
A.D.A. this person must have a long standing record of this disability and how it impairs
his or her life. Once this has been established and the person has been hired there are
still other guidelines set by the A.D.A. on how the employer goes about bringing this
person into the company.
This can be a very sensitive area for employer, applicant and existing
employees. Because of the fact that the person has a disability, undue assumptions made
by all parties involved. For instance, the new employee with the disabilitiy may assume
that the existing employees will think that he or she needs help with many trivial
things. Or the employer may tell the other workers to watch over this person for a while.
What should be happening is what ever happens when any other person comes in for a new
job,
that is introductions, respect, and of course training. The guidelines for
introducing a disabled worker are manualized in a book entitled "Employers Guide to The
Americans With Disabilities Act, Second Edition."
Requirements of the Employer
Probably the most important aspect of hiring a person with a disability is to
determine if that person is qualified to perform the job that he or she is applying for.
There is a standard definition of what defines a qualified person, "...an individual with
a disability who, with or without reasonable accommodations, can perform the essential
function of the employment position that such individual holds or desires"(Frierson, p.
106). This means that a worker is qualified to hold any job that he or she can perform
without an excess of changes to the business itself, as stated by the Americans With
Disabilities Act.
There is one aspect of the hiring process that could be mistaken as discrimination, but
is not. That is the employer is free to hire the most qualified person for the job. For
example, if there are two applicants for a secretarial job, applicant A types 65 words
per minute and applicant B, who happens to have a disability only types 50 words per
minute, even if the slower typing rate is caused by the disability, the employer should
hire applicant A because A is the most qualified for the job. However, there are
exceptions to every rule, and this is no different. Each instance is case sensitive and
must be handled accordingly. If there were two applicants for a telephone operator, both
are equally qualified but one has a hearing impairment which would require an amplifier
placed on the headset. This is not cause for choosing the applicant with no
disabilities, for the
reason that a telephone amplifier only costs a few dollars and is not considered to be an
excessive accommodation.
In Frierson's book, "Employers Guide to The Americans With Disabilities Act",
There are five practical tips on hiring practices which will keep employers
from violating any laws on hiring practices as stated in the A.D.A.:
1. In determining if a person with a disability can perform the job,
consider only essential tasks of the job.
2. Consider all reasonable accommodations.
3. After applying 1 and 2, treat job applicants with disabilities the same
as applicants without disabilities.
4. Hire the person who is most qualified.
5. Avoid blanket rules. Look at each applicant as an individual.
Decide if the individual is the most qualified to perform the
essential job tasks, after reasonable accommodations are considered.
These steps are very important not only to the disabled worker, but to the
person hiring the worker. This protects the employee's right to choose whomever he deems
to be the most qualified. After everything is said and done and the employer selects the
most qualified worker, and that worker happens to be disabled, there are some
accommodations to the workplace that may have to take place.
Accommodations made for the disabled are essential to that person becoming a
successful team member of any organization, for the reason that it allows this
person to do things independently and without having to wait for assistance.
"The Americans With Disabilities Act requires employers to make: reasonable
accommodations to the known physical or mental limitations of an otherwise
qualified individual with a disability who is an applicant or an employee..."(Frierson,
p.138). There is a list of reasonable accommodations as stated by the A.D.A., such
changes include making existing facilities accessible to those who have a disability.
Also acquisition or modification of existing equipment to accommodate all workers. On
the other hand, there are no set lists of examples that are considered to be in excess
for an employer to provide, however there are some basic guidelines for them to follow
when making this decision. For example, the accommodations are too expensive for that
particular company to provide. Also, the accommodation is seen to interfere
with the facility's ability to conduct business. An employer can be charged
with discrimination if that employer claims excess accommodation without researching all
the possibilities. An employer should never assume that accommodation is impossible,
there is a service provided by the "President's Committee on Employment of People with
Disabilities, called the Job Accommodation Network(JAN). JAN has literally tens of
thousands of ideas and suggestions on successful changes that have been made to
companies"(Frierson, p.165). So now there is no excuse for employers to make about
hiring a disabled worker, regardless of the situation.
The first two steps in the addition of a disabled worker are in place, the
hiring and the accommodations. Now there need to be programs in place in order
to effectively train these workers so they can be introduced into the workplace
and become successful.
Training of Employees (with motion disabilities)
Among all the disabilities a person can face these days, whether it be vision,
hearing, physical or mental disabilities, there is one aspect of disability
that tops the list of concern. That is a disability which impairs motion or
mobility of a worker. "Whether it is moving from home to work, form one work
area to another, or traveling long distances, the ability to get there tops
everyone's list of concern"(Tracey, p. 175). When a person has a disability that they
never had before, and they find that they cannot get around the way they did before, it
can be very traumatic to this individual. For instance it can cause feelings of
entrapment and loss of freedom. However with the assistance of a wheelchair and a
specially adapted vehicle, this person can regain that lost sense of freedom and begin to
re-build some lost self-esteem. Because most jobs out there require some sort of physical
or manual labor, a
person with a motion impairment of the arms, hands, legs or fingers can cause
some complications. However with a little effort and possibly imagination of a
few people almost all of these obstacles can be overcome.
There are numerous motion or mobility disabilities that an employer may have to
handle. Some of them are people with amputations, arthritis, brain damage, or
spinal cord injuries. Just because there are some individuals with these and
many other impairments, does not mean they should be denied the same
opportunities as any other person has in the workplace. In most cases there
are some assistive technologies available for companies and employers to take
advantage of. All of these are not considered to be an excess accommodation.
The most obvious of aids available to a disabled person returning to work is a
wheelchair or cane. These provide freedom of movement and independence in and
out of the office. Another very important, and relatively inexpensive modification are
the installments of ramps and lifts. If a worker has a disability which prevents him or
her from climbing stairs, ramps or lifts are essential. With all of the advancements in
modern technology, even a quadriplegic can hold down a job. There are actually
innovative programs in place to integrate the use of these workers either in an office
setting or in
their own home. As mentioned earlier, freedom of movement is important and without it a
disabled person cannot even go out to apply for a job.
This is where vehicle adaptations play a big role in the lives of Americas disabled
citizens. Help with making these adaptations to the vehicles of disabled workers can be
sought through that persons company. Also there are many vehicle manufacturers that
will re-imberse some of the expense put out by a company.
Personal Impacts made by The A.D.A. Regulations
One of the most important characteristics, we as humans posses is that of
self-respect. And in many cases of disability, individuals were not born with
any particular impairment. Once a disability has taken hold a persons life it
can cause drastic changes in that persons self-concept, self-worth, and the way
that person views the world. Before the Americans With Disabilities Act established a
foothold on ending discrimination against persons with disabilities, these valuable
citizens could begin to crawl their way out of obscurity and into the light of a
completely new world. Regardless of whether or not the A.D.A. is around, disabled
citizens are going to apply for positions. They had been doing so for fifty years before
the
A.D.A. In that time, the numbers of workers with disabilities grew from a few,
to a few thousand, to a few million. The change in trend is in direct correlation to the
A.D.A. and the statutes set by it in the workplace. First of all, Title I of The
Americans With Disabilities Act, ends all discrimination against disables workers. This
gives an opportunity for some people who might have been to scared to apply, a chance to
do otherwise and to do so on equal grounds. It also relieved some of the stress that may
have been felt by the employer because the guidelines are very clear and they are very
easy to understand.
Also when it comes to the actual job performed by the disabled worker, this
worker wants the opportunity to perform his or her job to the best possible
standards, just like any other worker. This is where the importance of the
special training programs and associations that are designed to aid in this
aspect come into play. Not only are the regulations helpful to the employer and the
employee, but a creative person can provide a sense of accomplishment
and even help to create a bond of understanding around all who are involved.
For example, the case of "a potato inspector who was required to core out bad
spots in potatoes. Carpal tunnel syndrome drastically reduced his ability to
perform the task. An adapted potato corer mounted on a table allowed him to
continue working at a cost of less than $33"(Frierson, p.161). It is things
like this that allow persons with disabilities to function as a productive
member of society. Or what is thought to be a productive member, in that this
person can be completely independent both in the home and in the workplace.
Technology, persistence, and understanding makes it all happen.
Now go back and look at the person who had a disability take control of his or
her life. That person is no longer, hiding in the shadows, he is out, proudly
contributing and living his life to the best of his ability. Also this person
can support himself with a regular paycheck, not a government aid or the help
of family and friends. This aspect in particular is of extreme importance to
many disabled Americans. The ability to survive on their own, not having to be
dependent on someone or some group to provide food, clothing or shelter, isn't
that what we all want anyway? That is why the Americans With Disabilities Act
is the most important precedent set in the struggle to end all discrimination against
disabled people. Although there will always be some discrimination and
prejudice against all groups in society, at least now one of those groups has
the opportunity to prove themselves in an unforgiving society.
WORKS CITED
1. The Americans With Disabilities Act Title I, 1994
2. Frierson, James G. EMPLOYERS GUIDE TO THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT,
SECOND EDITION, The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc., 1995
3. Tracey, William R. Training Employees with Diabilities, American
Management Association, 1995
WORKS REFERENCED
1. The Americans With Disabilities Act Title I, 1994
2. Frierson, James G. EMPLOYERS GUIDE TO THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT,
SECOND EDITION, The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc., 1995
3. Tracey, William R. Training Employees with Diabilities, American
Management Association, 1995
4. Conley, Robert W. The Economics of Vocational Rehabilitation, The Johns
Hopkins Press, 1965
5. Urbain, Cathleen Supported Employement: A Step by Step Guide,
PACER center 1992
|